Global Health Nursing & Midwifery
Quality of Nursing Care and Nursing Leadership in Nepal
Started by Laxmi Tamang on 12 Jun 2011
In Nepal, according to the recent Nepal Nursing Council record there are around 30,000 nurses in the country. Every year around 5000 nurses graduates in the country from both public and private nursing colleges. Most of the graduates do not get the jobs so some stay at home, some work as a volunteer, those who can afford to go abroad go for further study and very few get job in the private medical colleges and private hospitals.
On the other hand, in the national health care delivery system only 3000 nurses are currently working. In the government health care centres there are shortage of nurses but still government is not absorbing these graduates. Quality of nursing care is big questions in the health care delivery system of the country. Even in the oldest and largest public hospital like Bir Hospital managed by the National Academy of Medical Sciences (NAMS)the quality of nursing care is very poor.
Likewise, as per the last year record 40 years old Nepal Nursing Association has only 3000 nurses in their memberships.
Therefore, I always wonder what is lacking in the leadership of nursing in Nepal? Are nurses who are holding leaderships are incompetent? How Nepalese nurses leadership can be strengthened? What can be done to improve the quality of nursing care? How nurses who are holding leadership positions in the association can be empowered and make them accountable and responsible to strengthening nursing profession in the country?

Elhassan Elhassan
Dear Laxmi, I do appreciate your feelings about this situation. I assure you, do not get frustrated or feel bitterness, the fact that only 10% of your nursing staff are endorsed in health care delivery system. The head of the snake is that Our Governments are kneeling on knees in front of the Globe and the whole earth, which is only God Land and only God, being treacherously gripped by the international leadership, which I believe and think of as a big Fraud, The developed countries, you know took extraction of every good matter out of the developing world and again supported by our governments. Take yourself as an example, How could you proceed in your career without looking abroad to those North countries. The practice of discrimination is quite obvious on the world. Who can pay attention to what you are writing and keep repeating ? No body except us as scientists, who are supposed to behave like noble mankind. Is the service delivery system intact in those countries which are obtain your citizen nurses? Are they conducting the same poor service as in your country,Nepal?
expand commentDear Laxmi, the journey is too long for us to run.The targeted ...
4:45 AM, 13 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Kate Shaughnessy
Hello,
In response to the discussion about nursing leadership, the Oncology Nursing Society (ONS) has developed a leadership development/capacity building program that we have conducted internationally and was received extremely well. The intent is to strengthen nurses both individually as well as organizationally. We teach culturally-sensitive empowerment, so that nurses view themselves as advocates (for themselves, their patients, and their profession.)
I would be happy to discuss this with anyone, and we are always looking for ways to partner with other nursing associations, hospitals, and so forth to bring this to various regions.
Best regards,
Kate
_____________________________________________
Kate Shaughnessy, BA, CVA
Member Relations Manager
Oncology Nursing Society
125 Enterprise Drive
Pittsburgh, PA 15275-1214
+1-412-859-6238 (phone)
+1-412-859-6163 (fax)
Oncology Nursing Society
Where Oncology Nurses Connect
Learn more about membership today at www.ons.org.
Follow ONS
1:59 PM, 13 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Laxmi Tamang
Dear Elhassan, I couldn't agree with you more. Thank you for your suggestions and advice. I really feel good whenever I read your views and comments in different online discussions. It is really inspiring especially people like us who really want to make the difference in the society and in the lives of poor women and children.
expand commentI'm not going to give up my mission that easily to bring the changes in the health care delivery system of my country. The reason I’m doing currently my doctorate is also for that purpose.
Fifteen years I spent in the development sector of Nepal working through NGO, INGO and bilateral organisation but still despite having too many local NGOs (more than 40,000)/INGOs/bilateral and multilateral and donor agencies working and funding for the development of Nepal I hardly see tangible changes in the societies. Actually, I don't blame to our government it is the donor agencies we spoiled our policy-makers, planners and bureaucrats taking them unnecessary to international visits, not allowing or insisting them to work, not making them accountable to their commitments, providing too much financial support despite knowing the rampant corruption in the bureaucratic ...
8:33 AM, 15 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Lynda Wilson
Dear Kate Shaughnessy,
I would love to learn more about your leadership program. Our PAHO/WHO Collaborating Center on International Nursing offers a nursing leadership program for 3 weeks every 2 years and we are always looking for ideas on ways to improve that program and make it more relevant and useful...Any information would be helpful! Lynda Wilson ()...University of Alabama at Birmingham School of Nursing, Birmingham, Alabama USA
10:23 AM, 15 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Elhassan Elhassan
Dear Laxmi, I always find you enthusiastic and critical thinker, I do agree with you in spite of the fact that you do not, but disagreement is a sort of need to more discussion.AS far as we are searching answers for burning questions. The cultural, social, political and other so many factors are impedance of communication. But the major obstacle is this narrow space of contact, having other responsibilities to run: researches, students, postgraduates,patients service, networking, communications and library. I do apologize for that , but we have to shoulder it all and by its all redundancy. Remember , Laxmi that the needs of our people override even our own
personal capacity.
This large number of NGOS is supposed to act a big focus for the development. Think of building them as Leaders,try to arrange them the fact that they are NGOs and do not forget to build on capacity continuously, establish collaboration,coordination, plans of action, determine priorities, structure strategies, identify objectives. Why not, These are considered as organizations, there for must be organized.Women activists and women unions can play a major role together with media and public motivation.
2:56 PM, 15 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Elhassan Elhassan
The problem of manpower seems to deem the whole Globe,leave a part the situation in developing countries including African ones. The fragmentation is crippling the whole system of most of our countries.
expand commentIt is obvious that the capacity built of those countries is continuously collapsing and my view is that it is not only the capacity of health service system, but I am afraid that the human resources are very much deprived and the tendency of the situation is towards downhill. Nature has given to us what no body can imagine!. It is only the ever jeopardized human resources and add to that the so called (Brain Drain), which should not be very much annoying to us, as I can see , the fact the drained brain will continue to input for the sake of the mankind, what is wrong about that?.
By the way it might be strange to claim that , we as African and African countries are not Poor, but strange enough, considered as poor or some times described as developing. Are we really developing?. The answer is No, because we remain still very poor in front of the developed countries. I really feel very bad when I ...
7:17 AM, 16 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Elhassan Elhassan
Going back to discuss the issue of Midwifery as a global target, which really needs to be emphasized. The true facts are really required to address others by explains true facts. It had been a very long experience extended to around ten years back, when we, in Sudan started to think of the existence of midwives, nurses and other axillary staff. The biggest idea in Sudan concerning this issue is really dated back to very early, when we were students in the University of Gezira, The university was established in 1975 and the first batch intake was in the year 1978, since that time the university started its battle and the first global challenge concerning medical education . It was one of the first universities in the world which created the INNOVATION in the medical education.The story of Gezira is too long to be told by one person neither in quick comment It was very odd idea of innovation at that time when people used to call the medical schools as " Faculty of Medicine" and we were the first batches to be admitted to that school. Strange enough, we resisted the Dean Faculty Professor Basheer Hamad at that time very ...
expand comment6:24 AM, 18 Jun 2011 | Permalink
Joe Niemczura, RN, MS
Nurses is Nepal work in a "functional nursing system" constrained by the budget and lack of resources. To say the leadership is poor, is to blame the victim for the crime. I invite members of this group to read my blog www.joeniemczura.wordpress.com about the status of bedside nursing in Nepal.
7:54 PM, 1 Jul 2011 | Permalink
Laxmi Tamang
Dear Joe,
expand commentI respect your view but at the same time I am bit cynical with your opinion. Being a nurse with public health background I have worked directly in the national public health care delivery system and had 15 years experience working in the development sector of my country, Nepal so I know the situation very well. I'm not talking about the nurses working in the district and zonal government hospitals, where resources are limited.
Instead I'm talking about the leadership of Nepal Nursing Association, Nepal Nursing Council and Bir Hospital managed by the National Academy of Medical Sciences from where they can play major role in influencing policy makers and planners in strengthening quality of nursing care, and services in the public hospitals effectively and efficiently mobilising the limited available resources and strengthening nursing profession. In this world especially in resource-poor settings nothing is sufficient. There is always constrained of resources and budget but we've to learn to work in such situation and we have been doing this since our early age and career. By pointing out the contrained of resources and budget, there is no excuse for our nursing leaders. If they can't ...
11:32 AM, 4 Jul 2011 | Permalink
Tess Panizales, MSN, RN
One area we all can help on the above 'bulk' of issues that are continuously intertwined is helping to increase awareness of our younger generation through education - socio/political/economic/cultural not just the essentials of nursing. I remember throwing out a question to senior nursing students during a recent lecture in a developing country, '... oonsidering that most went to nursing for a job abroad, what are you going to do, now that there is economic meltdown and hiring is frozen?' - the room was quiet. 'Anyone helping in their community?' and so I went on to put that challenge to them. Hoping that it will make them think outside the box and focus on the wealth they can do to help the community even for an interim.
expand commentI do agree that professional nursing organization will have to be strong proponents to the interest of the country, and so does the Dept of Health to looked into ways to be able to utilize this educated nurses and find ways to decrease 'brain drain'. School nursing will be a great avenue to utilize nurses who are not working.
Mandela took a stand on this issue to reduce brain drain. Would be lovely ...
3:24 PM, 6 Jul 2011 | Permalink
Laxmi Tamang
Dear Tess,
expand commentI would appreciate if you could elaborate bit more about School Nursing as an avenue to utilise nurses who are not working.
Regarding the brain drain I'm not that much concern because wherever they go at least they are contributing for the mankind and we can't stop people mobility. I believe that it is a natural phenomenon to have wear and tear (i.e. people come and go) in this world. If some goes and other will come or produce, it is a continuous process. And in the case of Nepal, each year 5000 nurses are graduating and they find very difficult to find out the jobs because government of Nepal is not adequately absorbing them.
On the other hand, although government of Nepal says that there is a shortage of human resources in the health sector I don't agree with this because every year 1000 of medical students (doctors), 5000 nurses, 500 public health professionals, 1000 paramedics and 1000 allied health professionals are graduating within the country but government is not taking any steps to mobilise them efficiently to improve the health status of the rural people. In Nepal, we've 11 medical colleges ...
1:04 AM, 7 Jul 2011 | Permalink