Health IT
Suitable GPS enabled PDAs
Started by Owais Ali on 15 Sep 2010
Last edited by Robert Szypko on 03 Aug 2011
Dear All,
I am part of a team seeking to implement the X out TB intervention in Pakistan.
For those unfamiliar with the intervention please see the links below for more details:
http://mobileactive.org/x-out-tb-addressing-tb-noncompliance-mobile-phones
http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2008/tb-cellphone-tt0604.html
We are looking to distribute phones to our heath workers so that they are able to record the GPS coordinates of each of the 2,000 patients visited (since these patients will need to be revisited multiple times).
Moreover, we are also looking into the possibility of uploading our questionnaire on to the same phone to achieve quicker data entry (as opposed to manually entering the data from paper questionnaires using a code book).
To this end, any opinions/advice about the best phone to use for this purpose would prove very helpful given the wide variety of such devices that exist.
Thank you.
Keywords: Hardware Mobile Devices Monitoring & Evaluation

jason bygate
Hi,
We have successfully used the Nokia 2710 Navigator edition. This was using the on-phone mobile researcher application to collect data from home based care visits and to tag household locations. I have not tested Episurveyor on this handset as yet but I am fairly sure it would work.
Regards
Jason Bygate
Engage
3:08 AM, 16 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Jorn Klungsoyr
Hi Ali,
I suggest you contact IRD - Interactive Research and Development in Karachi (www.irdresearch.org) they are doing large surveys and MDR-TB control using mobile tools based on www.OpenMRS.org and www.openXdata.org
You may contact Aamir Khan at:
Best regards,
Jørn
____________________________________________________________________________
Jorn Klungsoyr
openXdata - Centre for International Health, University of Bergen, Norway
www.openxdata.org / www.cih.uib.no / www.openrosa.org / www.open-mobile.org
Mobile: +4791365731, Office: +4755588574, Skype/GoogleTalk: jornklung Alternative email:
Post: Postboks 7800, 5020 Bergen, Visit: Årstadveien 21, 5th Floor, Bergen
------¤¤¤¤------
3:52 AM, 16 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Richard Lu
Hi Owais,
Sana [http://www.sanamobile.org/] may be an option worth looking at, especially since it seems that X out Tb has roots in Boston. It can handle the use case that you outlined. (Full disclosure: I am involved with Sana).
Best of luck,
Richard
10:55 AM, 16 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Nicolas Pottier
How many different reporters will you have?
Have you considered XForms with HTC G1's?
They can be purchased for a few hundred dollars, you can run a great open source XForms client on them (ODK Collect) and they have a decent keyboard.
That would be my first inclination.
11:10 AM, 16 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Holly Ladd
We are currently implementing a project in Uganda that is collecting gps data and incorporating that into the forms on the phone for filed surveys. We are also capturing the photos taken as part of the survey. I would happy to speak with you directly.
We have previously used a gps enabled PDA for surveys in India and I can put you in touch with the people who worked with us if you would like.
Holly Ladd
AED-SATELLIFE
1:30 PM, 16 Sep 2010 | Permalink
niyigena john wilson
woow! that's interesting! i am interested in this project and if possible i
would like to have enough information about it,is there anyway we can
implement this in Rwanda?Please let me know the details and if you can help
it will be a pleasure.
Thanks.
2:06 AM, 17 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Owais Ali
Thank you all for your prompt replies.
I actually work at IRD and we are currently using the Nokia 2710 NE using openXdata. I just wanted to get a sense of what other alternatives were currently being used.
The HTC G1 while powerful, is around 4-5 times the price of the Nokia 2710, at least in Pakistan and does not seem very feasible for us.
I think we will stick with the Nokia phones for now, though I will definitely look into the possibilities mentioned.
Dear Holly thank you for your offer, I will get in touch with you should I have any further queries.
3:24 AM, 17 Sep 2010 | Permalink
john wesonga
Ali, Huawei recently launched a $100 Android 2.2 Smart phone in Kenya
http://www.engadget.com/2010/09/03/huawei-ideos-hands-on/ definitely worth
looking at.
--
John Wesonga
3:28 AM, 17 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Nicolas Pottier
The Huawei is an interesting option, though I wonder how well touch screen only data entry would work in the field.
FYI: New unlocked G1's are available in quantity for $250 on eBay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/New-Unlocked-T-Mobile-AT-T-HTC-G1-Android-Black-/26064886...
Which seems to be about twice the cost of the 2710's, but man, that is a way more capable phone long term.
Just out of curiosity how many handsets are you using?
-Nic
Nyaruka Ltd - http://www.nyaruka.com/
3:40 AM, 17 Sep 2010 | Permalink
Owais Ali
We will using around 10-12 handsets over a period of 2-3 years.
2:00 AM, 20 Sep 2010 | Permalink